The Stanley Parable – peering through the forth wall

Games are given a rather bad rap these days – all with violence and poorly written scripts about boring scenarios. Bland and unoriginal shooting arcades for pimply teenagers and oafs.

The Stanley Parable challenges this assertion, through sheer vision. It’s a short game, even with multiple endings (you’ll be done well under an hour), but the creativity is astonishing. You guide the protagonist Stanley through his oddest day of work, and unravel not only how bizarre his life really is, but end up reflecting on the state of videogame storytelling as a whole.

The game is coded using the Source engine, and is freeware, making it easily accessible to anyone who already possesses Half Life 2. Essentially, it is a mod, but it doesn’t use any of the original game – just its graphics and physics engine. Taking the form of a choose your own adventure book in video game form, the story is acted out by you, and the context voiced over by a narrator. The writing essentially comes out via the narrator, and they comment upon Stanley’s thoughts as you guide him around. The narrator’s voice is extremely well written and acted, but what is more extraordinary is the story. Everything is designed to be generic – the office, the work, and especially Stanley himself. Something odd happens to him in his everyday life (lo behold, every Hollywood movie or major game narrative), and we follow his adventures: choosing his path as we go.

The generic part is important, because you could pretty much layer any narrative into this framework. This framework is how The Matrix started, it’s how Half Life starts, it’s how a famous novel might start. It’s also (sadly) lazy story writing. Unlike a film or a book though, you get choices. That’s what makes videogames fun! It’s your skill and decision making that influence the plot, much like reality. The Stanley Parable crudely mocks this, though. You can’t win. There is no skill involved. Despite having choices, the narrator controls you at every turn, and only rewards you unless you do what they wants you to do. Much like every game you’ve ever played.

The Stanley Parable

This is unlike any kind of game I’ve ever played before. It smashes down the forth wall, and forces you to look at how unsatisfying the storytelling aspect of a game is. Instead of feeling like true worlds, you realise they’re more like disguised on-rails shooters, with storylines attached. Even games like Grand Theft Auto 4, with thriving sandbox environments, only really have a limited amount of plots for you to choose (none of which are really your doing – more the game designers).

I thoroughly enjoyed playing this, not just because of the excellent storytelling, but also for how thought-provoking it is. It’s definitely the first time I’ve played a game that was so meta – enjoyable in its own right, but something that can also enhance other games in the future.

Discoveries: Allo Darlin’ – Dreaming (alt version)

So, I’ve listened to my Indietracks mixtape recently, and I’m pleased to report two things: not only are there plenty of new discoveries here, but it’s very good (it also makes an acrostic ‘INDIETRACKS RULES’ when you look at the first letter of the artists!).

One of the new discoveries though, is plain odd. Along with Toby from The Punch Table, we’re pretty much the biggest Allo’ Darlin fans we know (15 live shows and counting). Which is why I’m startled to hear an unreleased version of their single Dreaming. It has the same structure, but produced completely differently.

Allo Darlin'

First off, it has a way more sedate pace. The ukulele part has completely changed. The bass is deep, loud and slow, and Elizabeth has an almost ghostly feel to her voice with a sad tone. Monster Bobby is also there, and his party hasn’t been changed much – but he never sounded happy in the first place. The original song is nostalgic and happy, easily worthy of a single. This is the kind of thing I would expect of Tallulah or Emily, it’s a soft song filled with regrets and dreaming of better days.

Here’s a sampler:

 

Indietracks highlights: Hidden Cameras save the day

I guess it would come as no surprise that this was the talk of the festival. The Hidden Cameras were one of the headliners – a band I have long (and unfairly) put off listening to properly. I’ve heard the singles, thought they were pretty good.. and then decided to devote my pre-Indietracks listening to Herman Dune, Crystal Stilts and Edwyn Collins. A shame, because out of all of them, Hidden Cameras have ended up becoming my favourite (well.. maybe Crystal Stilts).

On the Saturday, Hidden Cameras had been given the sub-headlining slot, just before Edwyn Collins. A source from Team Indietracks revealed to me that this was due to time constrictions – ideally they would have headlined different days. Help Stamp Out Loneliness had some technical issues, with the lead guitar stuttering halfway through the set. Then, suddenly, during Record Shop (one of their best songs!), all power suddenly cut to the main stage. No lights, no amps, nothing.

Help Stamp Out LonelinessThankfully they managed to get the main stage up and running again, for the rest of their set. Afterwards, Hidden Cameras were due to play. A large crowd gathered on the hill ready for them to play, but worse things were to come. They slipped past their due time, ten minutes, then twenty, then more. Eventually, Andy from Pocketbooks announced (without a microphone) that the main stage generator malfunctioned, and that there would be a change of schedule – everyone being moved inside. Massive confusion and disappointment in the crowd. At least everyone would be playing, but the inside stage isn’t as good for large amounts of people, and we’d have to wait til 11pm for Hidden Cameras. Rubbish.

Then, out of the goodness of their hearts, The Hidden Cameras said (I’m paraphrasing) – fuck it, we’ll play anyway.

Hidden CamerasWith their powerful vocals and their orchestral instruments, they did what few bands could, and played to hundreds acoustically. They didn’t have to do that. At Indietracks, nobody blamed the band, or the organisers, they had a plan and nobody would be let down. Still, they delivered a stunning impromptu mini-set in addition to their full set later. The crowd became silent in appreciation, at their dogged refusal to let circumstances ruin the evening. It’s a true testament to their showmanship – I think they just love playing live, and played just because they could. Only at Indietracks, eh?

Indietracks highlights: Northern Portrait in the merch tent

We are back in business, baby. I’m feeling considerably ill, and the post-indietracks blues are setting in. However, I have plenty of excellent photos (after borrowing a very nice camera) and some videos of special moments throughout the festival.

Northern Portrait

The first special moment is an impromptu gig organised by Scared to Dance in the merchandise tent, by the lead singer of Northern Portrait, Stefan Larsen. I missed Northern Portrait two years ago, and only picked up on them because of the phenomenal song In an Empty Hotel on the Indietracks 2009 compilation. No awards for anyone to guess their greatest influence (The Smiths), but their songwriting and talent are unbelievable, with some inspired songs that give a new twist on an old formula. It’s far superior to modern Morrissey (who is extremely variable and more than a little annoying), and it’d be difficult to find a Smiths fan that wouldn’t enjoy this jangle filled, crooning gorgeousness.

Even more surprisingly, it translates extremely well to an acoustic level. The singing is powerful and emotional, and there’s just enough jangle to echo the original. Below is a video I caught of their song I Give You Two Seconds to Entertain Me, a quieter song about being unimpressed with a seemingly perfect girl.

Gigs: Math & Physics Club @ Brixton Windmill

Silly Matt forgot that you need to put an SD card in a camera, otherwise it won’t take more than about 5 pictures. Very bad quality pics coming up (aren’t you excited!).

Support bands. First up, The Sweet Nothings. Despite being the weakest band of the night, they weren’t too bad. I worried I would miss them altogether (unlike some people I know). I’ve not seen/heard them before, making it difficult to judge their performance. I would say they’re pretty typical indie/shamblepop with some definite highlights – including a train themed song with train whistles!

Pocketbooks

Pocketbooks were the next band on. On any other night they’d be a good placement for second. Tonight, they’re bumped down by the two headliners, who have come all the way from the USA. It’s unfair though, because they put on a much stronger set than I’ve seen of late. I’ve spoken my concerns about their directions, but they pumped out some old classics (Falling Leaves and Fleeting Moments are as strong as they ever have been), and their new songs sounded great. Especially Promises, Promises, which seemed (strangely!) to help from a lack of violins and from stronger guitars.

Very Truly Yours have toured with M&PC throughout their tour of the UK. I may have incorrectly stated on Twitter and this blog that this was their first ever gig in the country, but I have been humbly corrected (they played Glasgow and Manchester). I must say that despite knowing nothing of them, they put on a strong set. They’re remarkably similar to Math and Physics Club, infused with twee. Female Camera Obscura-esque vocals and sparkling guitars make for easy listening. Whilst I compare them to M&PC, I’d say the songwriting isn’t as strong, and their rhythms aren’t as tight, but definitely enjoyable, and a great find. If I am free when they’re playing at Indietracks, I’ll make an effort to find them. I have a feeling I’ll leave during their set to stake out a place at the Church stage for A Little Orchestra, though. Oh and yes, that really is the best picture I could take.

Math and Physics Club

What you’re probably interested in is Math and Physics Club. Four guys in chequered shirts and thick rimmed glasses. I’d be lying if I didn’t say I’m biased on the subject. Around the time I got into the band was an important time in my life, and some of the songs have firmly rooted themselves into my emotions. April Showers was admittedly poorly performed but I enjoyed every moment of it – it has previously been one of my favourite songs ever (!) and it would be difficult for me not to. They’re not much of a live band, however, and it felt a bit rough at times, in contrast to their smooth production. The singer remarked it was their longest tour ever, ranking in at about three gigs thus far (no wonder they’ve not been abroad yet!). The guitar was tuned way up high, which worked better for some songs than others: Darling, Please Come Home sounded fantastic, and exactly like I would have wanted it to, but with more punch and emotion than the album version. I remarked in my earlier post that they had a gallery of hits, and most songs were either recognisable or sounded great. My favourite part was the fact that their encore consisted of “uh, what do we play now?” – and my dear friend next to me shouted for We’re So DIY. I’ve put that song on mixtapes before to describe the indiepop scene, and it arguably does a better job than Tullycraft’s Twee. “We’ll be the indie stars, that everybody hearts” – I think you already are, guys. I’m still undecided about Help Stamp Out Loneliness and these guys, but they put a very strong case forward. Maybe it’ll depend upon the weather.

Indietracks 2011: Who I’m looking forward to (part 2)

Oh gosh, oh gosh, only a few days left now. Check out PART ONE if you missed it!

Mat Palatano - Trains, Sunday

Mat Patalano

The Specific Heats are a crazy surf rock band from New York who have played Indietracks for two years now. To spice up the artists, they’ve imposed a rule that you can’t play if you played last year.. but the lead singer has found his way around it to play an acoustic set on the trains (a trick MJ Hibbett has also got around by appearin with A Little Orchestra). Yes, he wears a poncho, and they blew up a guitar amp two years ago during their set. The trains are always my  No amps on the trains, so I’m interested to see whether he does any Specific Heats stuff, or whether he’s got some solo acoustic work. Doing an acoustic version of the former would be my preference.

Crystal Stilts – Indoor Stage, Sunday

I have no idea why, but I keep acting like they’re not playing at Indietracks. Crystal Stilts are a shoegaze band heavily influenced by coldwave. Coldwave - to most people – pretty much means it sounds like Joy Division. Aside from the fact the lead singer sounds atiny bit like Ian Curtis, the direct comparisons really end there. But there’s a definite dark feeling in their music, and a capacity for some very catchy songs. Shake the Shacklesmade me sit up and listen when I first heard it – I could barely believe it was them. I enjoyed their first album Alight of Night, but it lacked a certain confidence, the music sounded claustrophobic, and the production quality isn’t the greatest. Claustrophobic I can deal with artistically, but when compared to their new album, it just doesn’t cut it. I’m nervous about seeing them live (as I never have before), because depending on how they set the sound up, it could end up being brilliant, or fall completely flat. Still, I’ve passed up too many opportunities to see them, and this one won’t be missed.

 

Jonny – Outdoor stage, Friday

Jonny, like Pocketbooks (mentioned in part 1), are playing the first night. It’s actually a great lineup for the first night – every single band playing are great. Jonny are a new supergroup partnership between Norman Blake of Teenage Fanclub, and Euros Childs of Gorky’s Zygotic Mynci. Despite the album apparently mostly written by Euros, Teenage Fanclub side seems more emphasised, with subtle melodies and harmonic vocals, and little to no synths. The album is pure bubblegum pop, and easy to digest, which makes for perfect Friday viewing. This should be a better choice than the frankly disastrous Everybody Was in the French Revolution… now!, who headlined friday last year – an inspired concept by Eddie Argos of Art Brut, with very mediocre songs.

Gigs: Jasmine Minks, Edinburgh School for the Deaf @ The Borderline

I’ve always had a problem with seeing C86 band revivals. They’re usually pretty underwhelming. Thankfully though, this was different, and quite enjoyable – although probably not worth the £10 price tag.

ESFTD

Edinburgh School for the Deaf were supporting. I’d been told they were ‘quite indiepop like’ from a friend. Apparently that means they’re shoegaze. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing: I like shoegaze. It just would have been nice to prepare my ears. They were quite loud. There were some great, emotive blares. Each song was better than the last – from underwhelming, to alright, to genuinely great. They have somewhat of a post-rock influence hidden in there, with an emphasis on structure and crescendos, but with dreamy, unintelligible female vocals. Again, drawing on shoegaze, using it as an emotive instrument and not depending upon lyrics (Loveless style).

ESFTD2

That said, the guitarists need to stop taking coke or something, because they appeared to unable to act like normal human beings. The bassist was constantly swaying and walking to and fro an entire part of the stage. Trying to put your bass guitar over one of the overhead rails? Seriously? It made me cringe, and even though the music by that point was great, it made me want to hate their music. The drummer, for the last song, came down into the front of the crowd and unleashed hell on a single drum he’d set up (see above), breaking the drumsticks spectacularly in the process. Musically, it was actually really effective, building to an awesome climax. Made me feel like I was a hipster and watching Gay Against You, though.

The Jasmine Minks were then ready to take the stage. Being a c86 era band, I’m ambivalent. Of course, I love c86 music. But seeing it revived is sometimes a painful process. They are definitely shambolic. That’s part of their charm. But it means that the experience can come off as shoddy, old and cheap. I’ve had some bad experiences with c86 revival bands recently – 14 Iced Bears are doing the rounds recently, I saw them supporting both The Pains of Being Pure at Heart and Allo Darlin’. I did not enjoy them. 14 Iced Bears are not terrible in small doses. But I could not stand listening through an entire set (sorry chaps). I also saw Mighty Mighty at Indietracks 2009, and would say it’s one of the most underwhelming sets I’ve seen in a long time. As for The Woodentops supporting Belle & Sebastian – blargh. Just mediocre and embarrassing. (on a bright note, I was very impressed with The Pastels doing a tour with Tenniscoats, and The Pooh Sticks were excellent at Indietracks 2010).

Jasmine Minks

So, you can appreciate my mixed expectations. I’ve been burned badly a few times. With 14 Iced Bears, I blame it on a lack of knowledge of their songs. The Woodentops generally had awful sound balancing, as hits like Move Me need a bit of punch. Given how good the sound had been for ESFTD, and I really like a solid 2-3 of The Jasmine Minks songs, I’m sure I could find something to enjoy in theirs. And I did! Whilst definitely not one of the best gigs I’ve been to this year, they managed to recapture some of their former glory. The start of the set was a little duff, but for the hits they brought on an extra guitarist (with a formidable moustache – we all know how important this is), which really helped add some oomf. Cold Hands, Warm Heart sounded great, as did Cut Me Deep, probably their most well-known song. I’d have to say the standout song was Think!, though – not only a personal favourite, but the bass and guitar sounded just right. And despite the fact the bassist looks a lot like Vince Cable (see picture), the song shows he has a great amount of talent. I’m not sure that those songs really made up for £10 worth of ticket, but it’s reassuring that some c86 bands have something left in them.

Indietracks 2011: Who I’m looking forward to (part 1)

Outdoor stage

Indietracks, as well as being the best place to see indiepop in the world, is also a personal highlight of the year. With only a week to go, I thought I’d give a run down of some of the artists I enjoy that are playing. Huge disclaimer, though: the joy of Indietracks is discovering something new. I haven’t heard of a lot of the bands on the list! There will be lots of new discoveries and crazy adventures, as there have been every year. Last year, someone from The Chemistry Experiment overheard a poor joke I made, and offered me a beer they had. We waited with Be Like Pablo in the queue for White Town, before they dragged us off to see Ballboy, with occasional chants of “Baaaaaallboy!” in thick Scottish accents. A crazy woman made me  feed a button to a fabric hedgehog, and then sang a beautiful song (that would have been a lot better if I wasn’t on my way to the toilet).

On with the bands. I think I’m going to do it in a few parts to stop myself getting exhausted.

Help Stamp Out Loneliness – Outdoor Stage, Saturday

A rare treat. Originally caught them at Indietracks 2009, and despite being underwhelmed at their appearance, by the time they started playing, they humbled me. A mix of deep female vocals, sparkling guitars, deep bass, and haunting synth, with heartfelt lyrics. The vocals are really the standout part: Lucille D Campbell’s voice is an extraordinary beast, sounding like a hash between Nico and a female Morrissey, especially given the deeply emotional lyrics. They describe themselves as indiepop / krautrock, but I’d venture there are influences from all over – resulting in a unique sound.

 

 

Math and Physics Club – Indoor Stage, Saturday

M&PC are appearing on at the same time as Help Stamp Out Loneliness, which I’m very conflicted about. I’m probably verging on seeing M&PC – not because they’re better, but because they’re from the USA and don’t play over here much (in fact, according to their website it’s the first time ever!). Math and Physics Club play indiepop in the finest tradition: every song is a heartbreak in twangy guitars and desperate lyrics, recalling both elements of The Smiths in their music, and Belle & Sebastian style vocals. Both of their albums are amazing, making it easy for them to play a set full of hits. They’re playing a special pre-Indietracks London show, which I am not going to miss for anything.

 

 

Pocketbooks – Outdoor Stage, Friday

Pocketbooks @ Indietracks 09The Friday is a very special evening, as for some it’ll be their very first taste of Indietracks. There’s only one stage, meaning everyone is together, and there’s no rushing around between bands. The atmosphere is friendly and relaxed. The opening band has a very special duty to fulfil, and I cannot think of anyone else better than Pocketbooks. They’re about the easiest band in the world to enjoy. I’m really looking forward to drinking a beer out on the hill, not a care in the world, watching the sunset behind the main stage, listening to some comforting and familiar tunes.

 

 

New single release: Pocketbooks – Promises, Promises

Pocketbooks 2008

Ah, it’s nice to look back, isn’t it? Pocketbooks, London’s most understated indiepop band, have released a new single. The thing about Pocketbooks is that they prove that indiepop has a check list. Tick enough boxes and you’ll get into the genre. Female vocals? Cool. Dress like the sixties? Sure. Act like the complete opposite of a rock star? Definitely. Pocketbooks are like a template for these qualities – they don’t really have anything unique about them. You’d think this would make them generic, but the band has a genuinely great catalogue of songs.

This new song, then. It’s called Promises, Promises, and it sounds a lot like it could have been their first album, Flight Paths. Except it has strings! Specifically, violins! The band doesn’t have violin players, they’re on loan from A Little Orchestra – a project led by Monster Bobby, mastermind behind The Pipettes. They somewhat dominate the track, along with Emma’s vocals. The two work well together as the primary focus of the song, the rest of the band inconspicuously doing their thing.

The song is typical Pocketbooks, which is a massive relief: recent gigs have hinted that they might take a new direction. More prominent keyboards in some new songs almost sound lounge jazz-esque, with no remarkable features or hooks, just a bland mushy blah of music. These are all new though, and I have no idea whether they’ll appear on the album. I hope not. More stuff like this one, guys.

You can download the track for free (yes, free!) here, and a stream is available below.